Are the Dutch Rude or Just Direct?
Lady Gaga, (remember her?) that rather talentless alleged singer, whose specialty appears to be making sub-soft porn pop videos set to music. Even though Madonna did all this in the eighties and nineties, Lady Gaga does her best to shock and ends up causing loud yawns for going over well-trodden ground. Which brings me to the subject of today’s post, a subject that has been discussed many, many times before, are the Dutch rude or just direct?
A common complaint from Expats upon arriving in the Netherlands is how rude they find the Dutch. Even some Dutch people returning to the Netherlands after being away for a few years share the same opinion. In a survey published in De Telegraaf in 2006, the Dutch voted themselves as the third rudest nation in the world behind the Russians and the French. The common response from some is that Dutch are not rude, they are just direct. Which is true? The Shallow Man will bravely go, where one, two or twenty men have gone before and will attempt to confirm if the Dutch are rude or direct.
Yes, unfortunately, I will have to generalize somewhat, and no doubt my comments will upset some. If as a result I’m captured by a group of angry Dutch people and made to watch the coronation of King Willem-Alexander, the not so bright, over and over again, I’ll stare fearlessly at my enemies and say, “Flikker lekker op jullie domme monarchists!” The things I do for my readers!
The things I do for my readers!
Rude, Oxford Dictionary Definition
Offensively impolite or bad-mannered:
Direct, Oxford Dictionary Definition
(Of a person or their behavior) going straight to the point; frank: he is very direct and honest
Are the Dutch Rude or Direct? You Decide
Depending on who you ask the Dutch are either often rude or direct. Far be it from the Shallow Man to take sides in this debate. Like a Judge that finds a member of his family about to be put on trial in his own court, the Shallow Man, due to personal reasons (close relations with the Dutch) will recuse himself from this debate and allow his readers to draw their own conclusions. However, I’ll provide some real-life examples of actual behaviors.
Don’t shoot! I was just telling it like it is!
Helpful advice on dieting
An English girl, who I’ll call Suzy, was having some issues with her weight. The fact that she kept bringing steak and kidney pies and other English delicacies to Amsterdam and consuming them in large quantities didn’t really help. While at lunch with some Dutch colleagues she happened to mention that she was on a diet to which one of the ladies present responded, “Not another diet? You keep doing these but you’re still very fat, perhaps you should eat less and do some exercise.”
Political correctness
A former Dutch manager of mine not long after I’d moved to Amsterdam once said to me, “From the telephone interview we had, I had no idea you were black. I don’t have a problem with blacks, it’s Moroccans I can’t stand“.
We have no word for that in our language
From a reader.
“I’ve lost count the number of times that people have bumped into me in the street and just walk on as if nothing happened. Words such as excuse me or sorry appear to be more difficult to get out of the Dutch than getting them to leave a decent sized tip in a restaurant. Is it a cultural misunderstanding? In the UK and in many other countries, it’s considered normal to apologize if you walk into someone, or kneecap them with your bag of shopping. Am I being too sensitive in expecting some acknowledgment when someone does something like this?”
A Dutch person actually apologized!
Every man and woman for themselves
“Shallow Man, I am an American and when visiting Amsterdam recently, my sister got on a tram holding a young child. Not a single person got up and offered her a seat. I could not believe that the men in Amsterdam were so rude.”
The Shallow Man will add to this that whenever I give up my seat on the tram to an old person, they often look as if they are about to have a cardiac arrest, that’s how unusual it is for people to behave this way, in Amsterdam at least.
From the NRC Handelsblad website forum
I believe that the way that Dutch react on Poles is an excellent example how rude can they be.
These are not just ordinary people that use rude language at the address of Polish. De Volkskrant called Polish in one of the articles “smerig volk” which I would translate to “shitty nation”.
Even the columnist of the NRC Next (the sister newspaper of NRC Handelsblad) Jan Blokker called Polish not so long ago on a national television “tuig” = “scumbags”.
Has he been direct? I don’t think so. To me, he has been just rude as one can be.
I could come with thousands of such examples.
What do you think?
So there you have it, above are a few of the common occurrences that lead some to conclude that the Dutch are rude, or are these common misunderstanding about behaviour and are they actually just direct and telling it like it is?
My own views on this are that I’ve encountered a lot of rude behaviour here, and continue to do so on an almost daily basis. That aside, I also know plenty of very well mannered and polite Dutch people as well. So what do you think? Are the Dutch rude, direct, or just jolly nice chaps?
No serial dieters were hurt during the writing of this post.
I have a West Frisian wife and am convinced some of Dutch directness is just autism spectrum disorder codified as culture. This region being the very epicentre. For example a colleague said “goh wat heb jij een smal koppie man” which translates into a comment about my narrow face. I asked him why he said this and he said “ja ik dacht ik zeg het gewoon” ie I thought it so I just said it. I kept asking what his purpose was with communicating this with me and he really just had no purpose or negative intent. He truly thought it and just said it. I wasn’t offended as I am used to it but more shock that this guy is completely unable to understand that maybe such comments don’t serve any purpose in relationship building. Perhaps autism traits were advantageous in the polder and resulted in more children. My wife’s family are all the same and can only have superficial conversations or if someone at a chair circle party says something controversial they will all sit there on their phone googling and correcting them.